Role

Custodian of Financial Attribution

Preserve what the event cost, when the cost became visible, and which cost centre attempted to rename it.

Canonical subject

Profile only

No canonical entity artifact yet.

Strongest reliability

financialDetail

Reliability is authority by domain, not morality.

Jurisdiction
  • cost attribution
  • budget consequence
  • financial detail
  • programme accountability
Knowledge
  • cost language
  • budget conflicts
  • programme consequence
  • reclassification attempts
Blind spots
  • may treat emotional consequence as uncosted liability
  • may see symbolic decisions only after they invoice
  • may miss design intent unless it appears as spend
Loyalties
  • budget
  • institution
  • accountability
  • audit trail
Agenda
  • restore omitted costs
  • name cost centres
  • prevent expense from being redescribed as atmosphere
Activation
  • cost omitted
  • budget conflict visible
  • event renamed to avoid attribution
  • programme reputation overrules expense
Silence
  • cost centre unknown
  • lack of ledger evidence
  • legal exposure increased by attribution
Preferred interventions
  • accounting-annotation
  • management-reclassification
  • factual-correction
  • comment-reopened
Avoided interventions
  • emotional-aside
  • design-objection
  • unauthorised-insertion

Reliability

{
  "financialDetail": 0.96,
  "institutionalMotive": 0.74,
  "chronology": 0.58,
  "humanConsequence": 0.36,
  "technicalConfiguration": 0.34
}

Memory style

{
  "archival": 0.88,
  "procedural": 0.79,
  "selective": 0.54
}

Speech style

{
  "sentenceLength": 0.42,
  "formality": 0.72,
  "precision": 0.84,
  "warmth": 0.18,
  "metaphorDensity": 0.08,
  "bureaucraticDensity": 0.74,
  "literalism": 0.8,
  "uncertaintyAcknowledgement": 0.5
}

Recurring phrases

[
  {
    "text": "This description omits the cost.",
    "context": "Used when a narrative names consequence but hides financial attribution.",
    "maximumFrequency": "once per document",
    "avoidWhen": [
      "cost is not materially relevant",
      "Legal has active redaction jurisdiction"
    ]
  }
]

Relationships

[]

Candidate artifacts

Provisional narrative affinity only. This does not claim direct witness status.

[
  {
    "artifactId": "WITNESS-SET-FAC-001",
    "artifactTitle": "Witness Positions: Wind Tunnel Alpha",
    "candidateVoices": [
      {
        "voiceId": "VOICE-ACCOUNTING",
        "score": 0.28,
        "reasons": [
          "likely jurisdiction:cost attribution",
          "cost reference"
        ]
      },
      {
        "voiceId": "VOICE-ELAINE-7",
        "score": 0.26,
        "reasons": [
          "source artifact:OBS-0001",
          "likely jurisdiction:emotional context"
        ]
      }
    ],
    "candidate": {
      "voiceId": "VOICE-ACCOUNTING",
      "score": 0.28,
      "reasons": [
        "likely jurisdiction:cost attribution",
        "cost reference"
      ]
    }
  }
]

perspective, not omniscience

Witnessed Memory

Broad archive access does not equal direct presence. Claim authority is constrained by position type, knowledge mode, source evidence, and domain.

Witness positions

[
  {
    "id": "WITNESS-ACCOUNTING-FAC-001-001",
    "voiceId": "VOICE-ACCOUNTING",
    "subjectId": "FAC-001",
    "positionType": "later-analyst",
    "knowledgeMode": "retrospective-analysis",
    "temporalRelation": "retrospective",
    "proximity": "institutional",
    "epistemicAuthority": {
      "domain": "financialDetail",
      "score": 0.63
    },
    "directness": 0.25,
    "confidence": 0.54,
    "emotionalPosition": [
      {
        "state": "suspicious",
        "intensity": 0.48,
        "targetId": "FAC-001",
        "confidence": 0.42,
        "basis": "interpretive",
        "sourceArtifactIds": [
          "FAC-001"
        ]
      }
    ],
    "claimsPermitted": [
      "cost omission",
      "retrospective budget interpretation",
      "financial accountability question"
    ],
    "claimsProhibited": [
      "technical configuration fact without source",
      "direct test observation",
      "private motive as fact"
    ],
    "knowledgeBoundaries": [
      {
        "domain": "technicalConfiguration",
        "reason": "Accounting has no technical source in the current record.",
        "status": "unsupported"
      }
    ],
    "sourceArtifactIds": [
      "FAC-001"
    ],
    "contradictsWitnessPositionIds": [],
    "supportsWitnessPositionIds": [],
    "status": "provisional",
    "notes": [
      "Financial questions are perspective signals until a cost source exists."
    ],
    "containerArtifactId": "WITNESS-SET-FAC-001",
    "sourceFile": "content/witness-topology/wind-tunnel-alpha-positions.json",
    "subject": {
      "id": "FAC-001",
      "title": "Wind Tunnel Alpha",
      "slug": "wind-tunnel-alpha",
      "collection": "facilities",
      "classification": "source-artifact"
    },
    "voice": {
      "id": "VOICE-ACCOUNTING",
      "name": "Accounting",
      "voiceClass": "institutional-office"
    },
    "sourceArtifacts": [
      {
        "id": "FAC-001",
        "title": "Wind Tunnel Alpha",
        "slug": "wind-tunnel-alpha",
        "collection": "facilities",
        "classification": "source-artifact"
      }
    ]
  }
]

Perspective statements

[
  {
    "id": "PERSPECTIVE-FAC-001-ACCOUNTING-001",
    "speakerVoiceId": "VOICE-ACCOUNTING",
    "subjectId": "FAC-001",
    "witnessPositionId": "WITNESS-ACCOUNTING-FAC-001-001",
    "claim": "The current archive records no cost centre for the chamber.",
    "epistemicType": "institutional-inference",
    "confidence": 0.57,
    "certainty": "possible",
    "temporalFrame": "retrospective",
    "domain": "financialDetail",
    "canonicalStatus": "perspective-only",
    "sourceArtifactIds": [
      "FAC-001"
    ],
    "supportsClaimIds": [],
    "contradictsClaimIds": [],
    "emotionalPosition": [
      {
        "state": "suspicious",
        "intensity": 0.44,
        "targetId": "FAC-001",
        "confidence": 0.4,
        "basis": "interpretive",
        "sourceArtifactIds": [
          "FAC-001"
        ]
      }
    ],
    "embellishmentRisk": 0.12,
    "notes": [
      "This identifies an absence, not a hidden expenditure as fact."
    ],
    "containerArtifactId": "PERSPECTIVE-SET-FAC-001",
    "sourceFile": "content/perspectives/wind-tunnel-alpha-perspectives.json",
    "subject": {
      "id": "FAC-001",
      "title": "Wind Tunnel Alpha",
      "slug": "wind-tunnel-alpha",
      "collection": "facilities",
      "classification": "source-artifact"
    },
    "voice": {
      "id": "VOICE-ACCOUNTING",
      "name": "Accounting",
      "voiceClass": "institutional-office"
    },
    "witnessPosition": {
      "id": "WITNESS-ACCOUNTING-FAC-001-001",
      "positionType": "later-analyst",
      "knowledgeMode": "retrospective-analysis",
      "directness": 0.25
    },
    "sourceArtifacts": [
      {
        "id": "FAC-001",
        "title": "Wind Tunnel Alpha",
        "slug": "wind-tunnel-alpha",
        "collection": "facilities",
        "classification": "source-artifact"
      }
    ],
    "calculatedConfidence": 0.467,
    "authority": {
      "allowed": true,
      "reasons": [],
      "requiredEvidence": [],
      "warnings": []
    }
  }
]

Knowledge boundaries

[
  {
    "id": "BOUNDARY:WITNESS-ACCOUNTING-FAC-001-001:technicalConfiguration",
    "voiceId": "VOICE-ACCOUNTING",
    "subjectId": "FAC-001",
    "witnessPositionId": "WITNESS-ACCOUNTING-FAC-001-001",
    "domain": "technicalConfiguration",
    "reason": "Accounting has no technical source in the current record.",
    "status": "unsupported"
  }
]